Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 9: Using Food

← Why So Big?The Easier Version →

Early, Not Late

There's one more thing to keep in mind, and the opening of this part of the book already said it: this machinery isn't a late addition. A cell has to get energy and raw material out of something. As far as the evidence goes, life can't exist without machinery that does this job — if not exactly this cycle, then almost surely something close to it. And the cycle's spread across all three great branches of life points to its being there early, near the very beginning. So the step-by-step story doesn't get billions of years to work with here. It gets whatever time there was before life's first branches split apart.

As usual, there's a standard answer. It says this didn't happen all at once. It happened in smaller pieces, not all the parts at once, over a long stretch of time. What we see today is the modern version, after ages of refinement; the earlier, simpler versions left no trace because they were swallowed up and replaced by better equipment. Some biologists point to the partial versions of the cycle still found in living things — a half-loop here, a loop run backward there — as hints of how pieces of it might once have been useful on their own.

Partial versions do show that a piece of the loop can be useful by itself. They don't show that the full loop was actually built that way, one useful piece after another, out of chance changes that, by the arithmetic above, couldn't find even one of these machines. For that, there's no evidence. There's a story. The story may be necessary to keep the whole enterprise going, but it is a story.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← Why So Big?The Easier Version →