Three Departments
The point is the one this book has now arrived at three times, from three directions. Getting from simple single-celled life to something like a human being was never going to be one problem. It was always going to be several quite different problems, stacked on top of each other, each belonging to a separate department of the project.
The first department was scale: building cooperating groups of cells at all, tissues and organs and a coordinated body, far more material working together than a single cell ever has to manage. The second was shape, an almost architectural problem layered on top of the first, since scale alone says nothing about what form all that material should take, or how it should be arranged in space. And the third has nothing to do with either. It's about turning living matter into something that can hold information and use it: process it, compute with it, act on it. That's a different kind of achievement from having the right amount of material in the right shape.
Some of the parts, once again, are old. Many of the proteins neurons use to pass signals are older than neurons themselves; versions of them turn up in sponges, which have no nerves at all. General-purpose parts can be prepared in advance, and these apparently were. But a brain is not its parts, any more than a telephone network is its copper.
All three departments had to be in working order before anything like a complex animal could exist. And the fossil record shows no long, patient run-up. In 2012, researchers described a fossil arthropod from China, Fuxianhuia, about 520 million years old, with its brain preserved: a three-part brain, with optic lobes, whose shape the authors compared to that of a modern shrimp or crab of the same size. That's from the same early stretch of the Cambrian as the trilobite eyes of Chapter 13. Complex brains were there almost as soon as animals with hard parts appear in the rocks at all.
So this part of the book ends where it began, with two questions. Could shape, instinct, and the brain have been prepared before bodies existed? The general-purpose parts, yes; the specific instructions, no, because selection can only test what has been built. And was there time? The answer depends on believing that, within a window of some tens of millions of years, undirected variation produced not one of these systems but all three at once, in animal after animal: bodies with precise shapes, programs that work the first time, and brains, built by rules nobody has yet deciphered, even for a worm with three hundred and two neurons, that the genome is hundreds of thousands of times too small to describe.
Last revised 2026-11-18