Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 9: Using Food

← The Machines, One by OneWhy So Big? →

What This Adds Up To

Sit with those numbers for a moment, because they change the shape of a question that has been with us since the earliest chapters.

Until now, the arithmetic has been built around a working model: a three-hundred-letter chain, drawn from an alphabet of twenty or twenty-six symbols, used to estimate how large a search space something like a working protein has to search. Those numbers were already staggering. But the actual machines running the most basic, most universal chemical process in the cell — the cycle living things depend on to get energy and raw material out of food — aren't three hundred amino acids. Several of them run to eight or nine hundred amino acids in a single chain, and some of the working units are three or four different chains bolted together, well over a thousand amino acids all told, just to move one carbon atom or a pair of electrons off a molecule that's barely twenty atoms in size. The eight machines of the cycle come to fourteen different chains and about six thousand amino acids — counting each chain once, and not counting the copies.

Give these machines the same generous rule Chapter 3 gave a three-hundred-letter protein: at every position, any of half the twenty amino acids will do. For three hundred positions, that left a target of ninety drums, already beyond the seventy-eight drums of tries the whole usable universe, turned into computers, could manage. By the same rule, citrate synthase alone is a hundred twenty-nine drums. The smallest machine in the cycle, the single chain at step 8, is ninety-four. Everything bacteria could ever have tried, in all of life's history, came to forty-five. So even if the machines could be found one at a time, each one kept as it turned up, every one of the eight is out of reach on its own. Ask for all fourteen chains together, as a cell needs them, and the rule gives one thousand eight hundred twenty-one drums. (The arithmetic: The Krebs Cycle Machines.)

That generous rule already widens the target for each chain on its own, as the opening of this part of the book said it might. It does nothing about the need for all of them to fit each other.

If a three-hundred-letter target already produces odds too small for any realistic number of trials to cross, a working machine several times that size isn't a bigger version of the same problem. It's a different problem, in a different league entirely, and the size of that league is not a modest step up. It's the difference between an already impossible number and something too large to usefully compare it to at all.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← The Machines, One by OneWhy So Big? →