How to Make Amino Acids
This quandary gets worse once we account for something quietly assumed the whole way through this chapter: the loading enzymes need something to load. Those twenty proteins do their job by taking an amino acid and welding it onto the correct carrier — but that only works if an amino acid is sitting there, ready, to begin with. Where does it come from?
The answer is that an amino acid isn't a raw material at all. It's the end product of its own chain of machinery, several tiers deep. One of the main ingredients feeding this entire chain is sugar. Some organisms simply get theirs by eating — taking in sugar already built by something else. Others, like plants, build their own from scratch. Either way, the sugar then has to be processed:
- Breaking that sugar down — 10 enzymes, the ten-step process mentioned in Chapter 4, producing several output molecules used differently downstream.
- Processing those outputs further — 8 more enzymes (the Krebs cycle, met in the last chapter), producing still more output molecules.
- Getting nitrogen into usable form — for organisms that take their nitrogen from the air, a nitrogen-fixing machine of several protein chains, plus 2 more enzymes, in nearly every living thing, to capture that nitrogen into a usable carrier molecule.
- The final assembly — one or several more enzymes, specific to each amino acid, finally combining a processed carbon-based output with the captured nitrogen to produce an actual, finished amino acid.
Add it up, tier by tier, and it comes to something like 120 to 130 separate enzymes — each one its own distinct protein, averaging perhaps 400 amino acids apiece — adding up to somewhere in the neighborhood of 50,000 amino acids of precisely built machinery, before a single amino acid exists to be loaded onto anything. (The count: Making Amino Acids.)
And every one of those 120-odd enzymes is itself a protein — meaning every one of them had to be built, in turn, by a ribosome, using loading enzymes, using amino acids, using this same machinery, to exist in the first place.
This is chicken and egg on steroids. The original version of the problem was already closed and circular: no ribosome without protein, no protein without ribosome. What this adds isn't a second, separate problem sitting next to the first — it's the same circle, discovered to run one full turn deeper than it first appeared. The amino acids fed into the ribosome aren't an outside ingredient arriving from someplace exempt from the puzzle. They're manufactured by machinery that is itself made of protein, which itself could only have been built by a ribosome, which itself needed amino acids to build. There is no floor here — no raw, protein-free starting material waiting at the bottom to break the cycle. Every tier you dig down through turns out to be built from exactly the same thing the whole apparatus was supposed to explain.
Last revised 2026-11-18