Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 15: The Brain

← Small Does Not Mean SimpleProblems Computers Have Too →

A Very Large Switchboard

Scale up from a few hundred neurons to eighty-six billion, and a different kind of difficulty joins the first. Not just "how does a small circuit produce behavior," but "how does anything get correctly connected to anything else at this size, without collapsing into chaos." People have solved a version of this problem once before, in a different medium, and looking at how they did it is useful, both for what it gets right and for where the comparison breaks down.

Picture trying to connect every telephone in a country directly to every other telephone, with one dedicated wire for each pair. The number of wires grows far faster than the number of phones: double the phones and you need four times the wires. A city's worth of telephones would need more wire than anyone could ever string. Telephone engineers hit this wall in the earliest days of the phone, and their answer was to give up on direct wiring almost entirely. Instead they built exchanges. The caller's number is read, and a switch, first a human operator, later a mechanical device, later a computer, finds a path and connects it only for as long as the call lasts. The system grew from a few dozen phones in one town to billions of devices worldwide on that same basic principle: read an address, connect only what needs connecting, when it needs connecting.

The brain faces a similar problem. With eighty-six billion neurons, it obviously isn't wiring every neuron to every other one; the numbers would be even more absurd than the phone company's. Something like addressing, and selective, targeted connection, has to be going on.

And the results are remarkably consistent. Memories are formed in essentially the same structure, in the same place, in every human brain. The same is true of vision, of language, and of countless other functions, each built in the same general place, brain after brain. Compare other species and the same overall organization holds, adjusted for size and need. That kind of reliability doesn't happen by accident. Whatever builds a brain is precise enough to produce the same architecture, region by region, every time.

But the comparison has a limit, and it's worth saying plainly. The telephone system was designed at every stage. Engineers worked out the addressing scheme, built the switches, tested them, and revised the whole system, generation after generation, leaving patents and blueprints behind. Nobody credits the phone system's solution to chance. The brain's wiring is proposed to have come about with no engineer and no blueprint, and, as this chapter will show, without anyone having deciphered its addressing scheme even now. The problems are similar. The stories of how they were solved could not be more different.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← Small Does Not Mean SimpleProblems Computers Have Too →