The Odometer
I ran the numbers. I owe you a refund.
Before I tell you why the get-rich-quick song scheme is dead on arrival, I want to back up and talk about something almost nobody thinks about anymore: the odometer.
If you're old enough, you remember the kind that used to sit behind the speedometer — a row of little drums, each one showing a single digit, each one clicking over to the next number as the miles ticked by. It's the same mechanism, more or less, as a combination bike lock: a handful of wheels, each one holding the digits 0 through 9, and the combination is just whatever the wheels happen to be showing when you stop turning them.
It's a wonderfully flexible little machine, and it shows up in more places than cars and bike locks. A one-armed bandit — an old mechanical slot machine — is really just an odometer wearing a costume. Instead of digits, the drums show cherries, bells, and bars, and instead of counting miles, it's counting combinations. Pull the lever, the drums spin, they land, and whatever they're showing when they stop is your result. Underneath the fruit, it's the same idea: a set of drums, each with a fixed number of symbols, and the whole thing displays every possible combination of those symbols as it works its way through them.
Here's the question I want you to sit with: how fast does an odometer's range grow as you add drums?
A single drum, digits 0 through 9, can show ten different things. Add a second drum, and now you can show everything from 00 to 99 — a hundred combinations. Add a third, and you jump to a thousand: 000 to 999. Every single drum you add doesn't add to the total — it multiplies it, by ten. A six-drum car odometer, the classic kind, can display exactly one million different readings, from 000000 up to 999999. Seven drums: ten million. It sounds like a small, boring rule. It is not a small, boring rule. It is one of the most explosive ideas in this entire book, and we haven't even gotten to the sonnets yet.
Here's how explosive. How many drums would you need on an odometer to count every single atom in an ordinary cup of water? The answer is around twenty-six. Twenty-six drums, each clicking through 0 to 9, can count higher than the number of atoms in the water you drink with breakfast.
Keep going. Every atom in every ocean on Earth — all of them, added together? About forty-eight drums. Every atom that makes up the entire planet Earth, oceans, core, mountains, atmosphere, all of it? Fifty-one drums. Every atom in the Sun — a star so large it holds more than 99 percent of the mass in our entire solar system? Fifty-seven drums.
And every atom in the entire visible universe — every star, every planet, every speck of dust in every galaxy we can see, out to the edge of what light has had time to reach us from since the beginning? That takes about eighty drums.
Eighty drums. Eighty little wheels, each showing a digit from 0 to 9, and you could count every atom that exists in the observable universe before you ran out of room. (How each of these counts is reached: Counting Atoms with Drums.)
This is, by the way, the entire idea behind a wonderful little corner of the internet built around the phrase "powers of ten" — interactive tools that let you zoom, step by step, multiplying by ten at every step. Take the smallest thing in this chapter that still has a size — the nucleus of an atom, a few millionths of a billionth of a meter across — and zoom out, times ten, times ten, times ten, all the way to the far edge of the visible universe. It's a genuinely dizzying ride, and it takes far fewer steps than you'd expect: about forty-two jumps of "times ten," and you've gone from something smaller than anything you'll ever picture in your head to the width of everything we can see in the sky. Forty-two. That's it.
I'm telling you all of this because I want you to have a feel for what multiplying by ten, over and over, actually does before I turn the crank on our own little machine.
Remember our song scheme? Twenty-five notes per song, twenty-five possible notes at every position. Let's build an odometer for that. Instead of drums showing digits 0 through 9, imagine twenty-five drums, each one able to show any of twenty-five letters — a through y, one letter for each note. Set every drum to "a," and you're looking at the song "aaaaa...a," twenty-five a's in a row: one very repetitive, very bad tune. Click the last drum forward one notch, and you've got a new song. Keep clicking, letting each drum roll over into the next just like a car odometer rolling past 099999 into 100000, and eventually — after every single drum has worked its way from a all the way to y — you will have displayed every single possible twenty-five-note song there is. Not almost every one. Every one, once each, no repeats, nothing missed.
That's the entire catalog. Every melody any composer, living or dead, human or algorithm, could ever write in twenty-five notes drawn from a two-octave range, sitting right there on those twenty-five drums.
So: how big is that catalog?
To answer that in a way you can actually picture, we need a second odometer — an ordinary one, with plain digits 0 through 9 — big enough to count how many times our twenty-five-letter machine clicks over before it's shown every song. And this is where the "add a drum, multiply by ten" rule comes back to bite us. Our song odometer has so many possible settings that the ordinary odometer needed to count them all requires thirty-five drums. Thirty-five digits, just to write the count down.
That number — the full count of every possible twenty-five-note song — is about 88,800,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000. Eighty-eight decillion, if you want to try pronouncing it. Nobody does.
Now for the part where I owe you your money back. Our whole scheme needed only one computer, generating one million random notes a second, tirelessly, forever, until it had worked through the entire catalog. So let's find out how long "forever" actually is.
The answer is about 2.8 sextillion years: 2.8 followed by twenty more digits. (The arithmetic: The Song Catalog.)
For comparison: the universe itself, as best anyone can tell, is about 13.8 billion years old. Our one laptop, cheerfully generating random notes since the moment I cashed your thousand dollars, would need something like two hundred billion times the entire current age of the universe to work its way through every possible twenty-five-note song — and that's assuming it never once repeats itself, never breaks down, and never needs a coffee break.
So. About that thousand dollars. I'm going to go ahead and return it.
But notice what just happened, because it's the whole engine of this book. Twenty-five drums. Twenty-five letters each. A number so large it needs thirty-five digits just to write down, and so long to generate randomly that it dwarfs the age of the universe itself, by a factor with twelve digits of its own.
And a Shakespeare sonnet, remember, isn't twenty-five letters long. It's closer to three hundred.
Last revised 2026-11-16