Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 12: RNA World to the Rescue?

← Making the LettersWhere Could This Have Happened? →

Joining RNA Letters

Suppose, for the sake of argument, that the RNA World somehow got its letters — that ribose, base, and phosphate found some way to come together despite everything just described. That still isn't RNA. A single nucleotide is a letter, not a message. To do anything useful, letters have to be strung together, one after another, into an actual working chain — and that joining step turns out to be its own separate, serious problem, distinct from making the letters in the first place.

Here's how it happens today. A modern cell doesn't join two resting, ordinary nucleotides together — it can't. The building blocks it actually uses arrive pre-loaded with extra phosphate groups attached, like a spring already wound. Forming the new link releases two of those phosphates at once, and that release is what powers the connection. The energy needed to do the joining is built directly into the raw material, spent the instant it's used. Nothing about this joining step happens for free.

So the real question is: where would that same energy have come from on the early Earth, with no cell, no enzyme, and no pre-loaded building blocks supplied by any living process? Researchers have tested this directly, and the answer is: only with substantial outside help, and even then, only partially.

Plain nucleotides sitting in water simply don't link up. Nothing happens. To get any joining at all, researchers first have to chemically "activate" the nucleotides — attaching a different, energetic chemical group in the lab to stand in for the phosphate spring a modern cell provides naturally. Even with that activation done for them, the reaction still needs something to hold the pieces in place: an existing strand of RNA acting as a guide, or a mineral surface, such as certain clays, that holds the new pieces close together long enough for the connection to form. And the best current versions of this chemistry only work reliably under fairly specific conditions — one recent approach requires the mixture to go through repeated cycles of freezing and thawing to get the joining to happen at all.

Strip away the laboratory assistance, and what's left is not encouraging. Nobody has demonstrated ordinary nucleotides joining into a working chain using nothing but the raw materials and conditions the early Earth would plausibly have offered on its own — no chemist pre-loading the pieces, no carefully prepared surface or strand standing by as a guide. The physical joining step, in other words, isn't a detail to be waved past. It's a second, independent barrier, sitting right behind the barrier of making the letters in the first place — and on the evidence available, chains don't seem to build themselves any more easily than their individual letters do.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← Making the LettersWhere Could This Have Happened? →