Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 12: RNA World to the Rescue?

← Where Could This Have Happened?Is RNA a Great Savior? →

Can RNA Do Real Work?

There's a pattern worth noticing in everything the last two chapters described. Almost every job that requires repeated, driven motion — prying two strands of DNA apart, dragging a ribosome forward one position at a time, unfolding a misshapen protein, forcing two pieces together against resistance — is done by a protein. RNA's own contribution, even at the one spot where it takes center stage, the ribosome's own reaction site, isn't the driving force. The ribosome's RNA does shift and ratchet as the machine works, but the push comes from proteins. What the RNA supplies at the reaction site is precise positioning — holding two pieces exactly where they need to be so a reaction can happen, not reaching out and doing anything to make it happen.

That's worth taking seriously as a limitation, not just an observation. RNA can do some chemistry: there are RNA molecules in nature that cut a chain at one particular spot, or join two pieces together, and laboratory-made ones that can copy short stretches of RNA, as Chapter 5 described. But the heavy, repeated, driven work — copying long chains again and again, unwinding a folded structure to work on it, pulling, dragging, forcing — belongs, in every cell we can actually examine, to proteins almost without exception.

Which raises a real problem for a genuine RNA World. If RNA is, by its own nature, poorly suited to any job requiring sustained, repeated mechanical work, then a world with RNA alone would have needed some way to build itself — to actually assemble its own working chains, again and again — without access to the one class of tool every modern cell relies on to do exactly that kind of assembly. It isn't just that the RNA World has no demonstrated way to copy itself efficiently, which was already a problem on its own. It's that the very category of ability such copying would require doesn't seem to be something RNA does well at all, even now, with three and a half billion years of opportunity to have kept or refined the ability if it were ever there. An RNA World wouldn't just have struggled to reproduce efficiently. On this evidence, it's hard to see how it would have been able to build itself in the first place, or survive long once built, without the very machinery it was supposed to exist before.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← Where Could This Have Happened?Is RNA a Great Savior? →