Steering by the Sun
It helps to see what steering by the sun takes, by asking how people learned to do it.
The sun is a poor compass on its own. It rises roughly in the east and sets roughly in the west, but "roughly" hides a great deal: the exact direction of sunrise swings by dozens of degrees over the year, and the sun moves across the sky quickly in some hours and slowly in others, at rates that depend on the date and on where you are. To get a direction from the sun, you need to know the time, the date, and how the sun's position depends on both.
Human navigators took a very long time to master this. Portuguese sailors in the late 1400s learned to find their latitude by measuring the sun's height at noon, using printed tables of where the sun would be on each day of the year, tables that took astronomers centuries to perfect. Finding longitude, how far east or west you are, was harder still, because it needs an accurate clock that keeps time at sea. That wasn't solved until the 1760s, when the English clockmaker John Harrison built a chronometer accurate enough to do it, after decades of work and a famous government prize. Until satellite navigation arrived, a ship's navigator still worked out a position with a precise instrument, an accurate clock, a book of tables, and a page of arithmetic.
A migrating bird or butterfly has none of those aids. It has the sun, a clock inside its body, and whatever its nervous system does with them.
To be fair to the evidence, birds don't seem to be born with the whole solution. Experiments with homing pigeons show that young birds have to learn the sun's path: pigeons allowed to see the sun only in the morning can't use it to steer in the afternoon. The stars work the same way. In the 1960s, Stephen Emlen raised young indigo buntings, small North American songbirds, under a planetarium sky. The birds learned to find the point the stars appeared to turn around, and steered by it. When he made the planetarium sky turn around a different star, Betelgeuse in the constellation Orion, the birds took Betelgeuse to be north.
That's a beautiful design, because the sky itself drifts. Over about twenty-six thousand years, the slow wobble of the Earth's axis changes which star sits nearest the point the sky turns around; Polaris won't always be the North Star. A bird born knowing "steer by Polaris" would eventually go badly wrong. A bird born knowing "find whatever point the sky turns around, and use that" never needs to notice the change.
But notice what that means. What's inherited isn't an answer. It's a procedure for finding the answer: watch the sky, find the turning point, learn the sun's path, combine it with the clock, and fly at the right angle to the result, at the right time of year, in the right direction for your population. The content is learned. The program for learning it, and for using what's learned, is built in, and it has to work in a bird that has never done any of this before.
Last revised 2026-11-18