Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 14: Instinct

← How Many Instincts?Chapter 15: The Brain →

A Different Kind of Program

Step back from migration and consider an example this book has mentioned before in passing: a spider building its web. It exposes something the standard story handles well in one setting and much less comfortably in another.

This book has granted that an existing protein can sometimes be improved in small steps. Laboratories do it routinely, by making many random variants of a working protein, testing them, and keeping the best; the method is called directed evolution. It works because a protein is a single physical object, and a small change to its sequence usually makes a correspondingly small change to its shape or behavior. That's exactly the kind of gentle, forgiving landscape that gradual improvement needs.

A web isn't that kind of object, and building one isn't that kind of task. Watch an ordinary orb-weaving spider, and the building happens in distinct stages. First comes a bridge line: a thread let out on the breeze until it catches on some distant support. The spider crosses it, drops a second line below, and uses the tension to find where the center of the web will be. From the center it lays out frame threads and a few dozen spokes, evenly spaced, out to the rim. Then it spins a temporary spiral outward from the center as scaffolding, and finally reverses direction and lays the sticky capture spiral back inward, removing the scaffolding as it goes, and deciding where to attach the thread at every single spoke it crosses. Researchers studying that one decision have found the spider weighing several different cues each time. All of it, start to finish, with no parent ever showing it a single step, and no chance to practice.

Now ask what "improving" a program like that would mean. A small change to a protein usually nudges its shape a little. There's no reason to expect a small change to a set of staged instructions to stay small in its effect. Some changes might: slightly wider spacing between the spokes, a slightly stickier thread. But later stages depend on what earlier ones established. Change how the center is found, or skip a stage, and everything built afterward has to change to fit.

This isn't a hypothetical worry. Nature has an example of exactly that kind of reorganization. Darwin's bark spider, from Madagascar, builds the largest orb webs known, slung across rivers on bridge lines up to twenty-five meters long. It doesn't follow the standard sequence. It does almost no exploring of the site first. It releases unusually large amounts of silk to drift across the water, instead of a single modest bridge line. And whereas every other orb-weaver studied builds the center of its web as part of that first bridge line, this one builds the center separately, from scratch, afterward. The researchers who filmed it describe some of these behaviors as unknown in any other spider. It's not a tweak to the usual program but a reorganized one, evidently evolved together with the spider's unusually tough silk and its unusual habitat.

How a change like that could build up gradually is an open question, and almost nothing is known about the mechanism. Nobody knows how a staged sequence of behavior like this is written into a genome in the first place, let alone how it could be rewritten one small step at a time without the rest of the sequence collapsing into nonsense along the way.

One thing seems clear enough to say now. Whatever happens when a web design changes, it isn't the same thing as a single mutation nudging one amino acid in a protein. A protein and a staged behavioral program are different kinds of objects, in different kinds of landscapes, and there's no good reason to assume that what's true of the gentle one tells us anything reliable about the other.

Which leaves the hardest question of all for last. A cuckoo chick's ejection routine, a bird's sun compass, a spider's building sequence: wherever these programs are written, they run on a brain. The next chapter is about the brain itself.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← How Many Instincts?Chapter 15: The Brain →