Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 11: Building the Machine That Builds Everything

← When the Helpers Are RemovedChapter 12: RNA World to the Rescue? →

Already There

And more significant still: much of this apparatus is ancient.

A study published in 2024 offers the best current estimate of just how ancient. Researchers built a "molecular clock," comparing how much genetic difference has built up between living organisms today, calibrated against fossil and chemical evidence from the rocks, to work backward and estimate when the major branches of life split apart. The study strengthened the method by using genes that had already doubled before life's very first split, which gave two related copies of the same clock to check against each other. Its answer for LUCA — the last universal common ancestor, the single ancestor shared by every living thing on Earth — is about 4.2 billion years ago (somewhere between 4.09 and 4.33 billion). And the researchers reconstructing LUCA's likely set of genes describe it not as a crude beginner, but as an organism on a par with the simple cells alive today.

The genes used to set that clock are telling in themselves. There were five pairs, each pair descended from a single original gene that had already doubled before LUCA existed. One pair belongs to the machine that turns fuel into the cell's energy currency, so that machine was already built, and already duplicated, by then. Another pair is the two escort proteins from the last chapter, the one that delivers each loaded carrier and the one that drives the ribosome forward. A third belongs to the system that sends newly made proteins to the cell's membrane. And two more pairs are loading enzymes, the ones that match a specific amino acid to its carrier. Those two pairs alone tell us something specific: at least four different amino acids already had their own dedicated, distinct loading machinery, which means a genetic code that told specific amino acids apart was already well underway. Broader reconstructions of LUCA's genes go further still, concluding that LUCA already had a working system for starting the ribosome on a fresh message, and loading machinery for most, though apparently not quite all, of the twenty amino acids in use today.

We can't know most of this for certain. But studies using molecular clocks to reconstruct what existed at that early stage keep turning up the same basic answer: the ribosome, a genetic code close to the one every living thing still uses, and a good deal of the supporting cast of proteins and RNA that let a cell turn information into a finished product were already there.

In other words, very close to the beginning of life on this planet, life was already, at the very least, quite complex — a degree of complexity that ought to be startling, given how little time existed before that point for anything resembling trial and error to run its course. Chapter 5 argued that something, in this story, was in a hurry. Whatever it was did a remarkable amount of work, remarkably quickly — geologically speaking, in the blink of an eye — considerably more, it would seem, than chance can reasonably be supposed to have had the chance to do.

The standard reply, once again, is the RNA World: before any of this existed, RNA did it all alone, and the apparatus described in these two chapters grew up later, out of it. How much time that would have needed, and whether it could ever have worked at all, is the subject of the next chapter.

Last revised 2026-11-18

← When the Helpers Are RemovedChapter 12: RNA World to the Rescue? →