Chapter 5: A Universe in a Hurry
Three Proteins
Which brings us to the question this chapter is built around: before any packaging existed — before there was a package for anything to be packaged into — how would even a handful of these specific, correctly built pieces have ended up in the same place at the same time, purely by chance?
Let's find out — with a clear warning about exactly what kind of answer we're about to get.
Nobody has solid numbers for most of the quantities this question depends on. We don't know how many different amino acid sequences could work as, say, "a protein that captures energy from the environment," versus how many ways there are to fail at that job. Published research has tried to estimate figures like this for particular proteins — some of it finding numbers in the same neighborhood as the ones we've been working with, some of it disputed even within the scientific community that produced it — but nothing that adds up to a reliable, agreed-upon total for the picture as a whole.
So what follows is not a claim to real, measured numbers. It's a thought experiment: a deliberately simplified, back-of-the-envelope exercise, built on the illustrative numbers we've already developed, meant to show the shape of the problem rather than pin down its exact size.
Here's the setup, and look carefully at how much it gives away.
Start with every possible way of stringing twenty amino acids into a chain three hundred long. As we saw in Chapter 3, that's about ten to the three hundred ninetieth chains. In reality, the vast majority of them would be completely useless to life.
First concession: we'll allow every one of them to be useful. Not one chain is junk.
Second concession: we'll take those chains in groups of ten to the three-hundredth — the size of the family we allowed for a single protein in Chapter 3, where any of half the amino acids could sit at each position — and treat every chain in a group as doing exactly the same job. That leaves ten to the ninetieth groups, each one doing its own job, every chain in it useful, and every chain in it doing exactly the same thing.
Third concession: we'll take those ten to the ninetieth groups and join them, ten to the fortieth at a time, into "super classes," treating everything in a super class as doing the same job too. Each super class now holds ten to the three-hundred-fortieth different chains, all counted as one and the same for our purposes.
That still leaves ten to the fiftieth super classes.
Fourth concession: we'll ask for only three. We've already seen that the simplest cell known needs hundreds of different proteins — four hundred seventy-three genes in the stripped-down laboratory cell, around thirteen hundred in the leanest organism living on its own. Asking for three is itself an enormous concession. So: just three specific super classes, working together — one to capture energy from the environment, one to put that energy to use, and one to handle reproduction. The bare minimum of a going concern, reduced to its three most essential jobs.
Now, how many protein molecules could the early Earth have held at any one time? Let's stay with what's realistic. All the bacteria alive on Earth today — about five times ten to the thirtieth cells, each holding a few million protein molecules — add up to something like ten to the thirty-seventh protein molecules. Let's grant the early Earth ten to the fortieth: about a thousand times all the protein in all of today's bacteria, on a planet that, at the start, had no cells at all to make any. Nobody has the faintest idea how you'd get anywhere near that many protein molecules with nothing alive to make them — but this is a thought experiment, so let's grant it anyway.
With ten to the fortieth protein molecules spread across ten to the fiftieth super classes, the chance that even one of those molecules belongs to a particular super class, at a given moment, is about one in ten billion. Needing all three of our super classes — energy capture, energy use, reproduction — present at once means multiplying that chance by itself three times: one chance in ten to the thirtieth.
Now give it time — but, again, only the time the evidence allows. Go back to how this chapter opened: whatever happened, happened fast, within a few hundred million years of the Earth becoming survivable. Let the whole population of Earth's proteins reshuffle itself completely, once every second, for five hundred million years — about ten to the sixteenth separate attempts. The chance of all three super classes ever showing up on Earth at the same moment, even once in all that time, comes to about one in sixty trillion. Give it the entire age of the universe instead, nearly thirty times as long, and it's still only about one in two trillion. (The arithmetic: Three Proteins.)
And that's before asking whether, having beaten those odds, the three molecules would ever actually manage to find each other — and there's virtually no chance at all that three such molecules, scattered among ten to the fortieth others across the whole Earth, would be anywhere near each other.
Look again at what we gave away to get here. Every possible chain useful. Ten to the three-hundredth different chains counted as doing exactly the same thing. Then ten to the fortieth of those groups lumped together as doing the same thing again. And only three kinds of protein asked for, where real life needs hundreds. Even so, there are still so many super classes left — ten to the fiftieth — that members of just three particular ones can't be expected to turn up on Earth at the same time, ever.
I don't see how anyone could be more generous than that. If you think it's possible, explain how.
A word on why I've been careful to keep the number of molecules realistic. Time counts only once: twice as long gives twice the chance. But the number of molecules counts three times over, once for each protein we need, so ten times as many molecules makes the chance a thousand times better. That's why this number can't simply be pushed up "to be generous." It has to be what the Earth could actually have held — and ten to the fortieth is already far beyond that.
Nobody watching this unfold would call it a strong case for chance. And yet — remember what we established at the start of this chapter. However it happened, it happened fast.
Last revised 2026-11-17