Evolution and Arithmetic

Chapter 3: A Panorama of Life

← How Many Species?One Sonnet a Year →

How Different Are Two Species?

One more piece before we put this together. How different is one species from the next, genetically speaking?

There's no direct way to measure that, because we can't set a species side by side with its immediate ancestor. The nearest we can come is two living species that are close cousins. Take humans and chimpanzees — said to have split from a common ancestor about six or seven million years ago.

How different are their genomes? That depends on what you count, and different ways of counting reach very different answers. Count only the places where one letter has been swapped for another, and the two are about 99 percent identical — the figure you've probably heard. Count also the stretches of DNA that were added or lost in one line or the other, and the figure drops to around 95 percent. Count everything in the recently completed ape genomes, including stretches so different that they can't be lined up against each other at all, and it drops further still. Scientists argue over which of these is the right way to count, and I won't settle that argument here. For our purposes it doesn't matter, because even the smallest count is a big number. One percent of a three-billion-letter genome is some thirty-five million letters.

But that is not the difference between one species and the next. Since the split, each line has passed through a number of species — some of them known from fossils in our own line, all of them inferred for the chimpanzee's. So the total difference is spread over many steps, and any one step may have involved much less change.

Not all of the difference matters, either. Much of it may be what is called genetic drift: changes in the genome that don't affect anything at all. And not all of what does matter builds proteins. A great deal of DNA does other kinds of work entirely — shaping how and when genes switch on, influencing physical structure, quite possibly even bearing on things like instinctive behavior. It's not all recipe; some of it is more like scheduling and stage direction.

So spread the difference as thin as you like. Take the smallest count. Set aside nine-tenths of it as drift that does nothing. Split what's left between the two lines, and divide our share over, say, fifteen species from the common ancestor to us. Each step still comes to more than a hundred proteins' worth of change. (The arithmetic: Human and Chimpanzee.) Count any other way, and the figure only grows. I'll come back to this calculation, more carefully, in a later chapter. For now, one thing is already clear: however you count, one three-hundred-letter protein's worth of change per species is ridiculously small.

All this may seem somewhat surprising, since we like to think of ourselves as very different from chimpanzees. But much of the genome is busy doing basic work — making proteins, shaping the body and its organs, and so on. The body plans and the basic chemistry of humans and chimpanzees are more or less the same. There are vast differences, especially in brain size and function. Apparently, DNA is clever enough to pull this off while changing only a small percentage of its total sequence.

Last revised 2026-11-17

← How Many Species?One Sonnet a Year →